EDINBURGH ’09 dispatches (page 4) Sun.21.June : ‘Jerichow’, ‘Kicks’, ‘The Architect’, etc

#6.1 (5.15pm, Sunday 21st June)
I went along to Jerichow on Friday night having seen it for the first time at Rotterdam back in January. Writer/director Christian Petzold is among my very favourite film-makers currently operating, and this one originally struck me as a solid but slightly below-par effort from the man responsible for The State I Am In, Yella and Something To Remind Me. But subsequently reading numerous other critics hailing it as among his finest work, I was keen to give it another go. I duly did so in Edinburgh this week and – to my surprise – I ended up liking it less, not more.
Admittedly, there's much to appreciate in this three-hander about a cash-strapped former soldier, the Turkish snack-kiosk operator he starts working for as a driver/factotum, and the latter's smoulderingly seductive wife (it's a partial update of James M Cain's The Postman Always Rings Twice). But by the end I couldn't silence a nagging "so what?" feeling about the enterprise: what, if anything, is Petzold saying about the situation of Turkish immigrants in modern Germany (the Turkish character here, though often sympathetically portrayed, is also a violent wife-beater).
And I wasn't sure what to make of the way Petzold's plot diverts from the Cain original right at the end in a manner that's ironic and abrupt, but doesn't really bring any new insight or interest to the story. Also, Petzold – most unusually for him – relies on implausibility and coincidence at crucial junctures (such as the moment when the husband realises that his wife and his employee are plotting against him), and overall there's the impression that the director, for all his skill and efficiency, is operating on something approaching auto-pilot.
If Jerichow disappointed, British drama/thriller Kicks exceeded expectations. Indeed, the first half – in which we're introduced to a pair of Liverpool lasses (late teens / early 20s) who lust after a star local footballer, and are horrified to learn of his imminent move to Madrid – had me wondering whether the picture might turn out to be one of the finds of the festival. An atmospheric, slyly topical character-study of young women whose chief aspiration is to be a 'WAG' (the tabloid's term for footballers' Wives And Girlfriends), these early stretches played a bit like a cross between My Summer of Love and Awaydays, with the girls and their Merseyside milieu very deftly sketched via slick digital cinematography and melancholic, yearning synth-electro pop.
Such a shame that when push came to shove and the script buckled down the business of getting the plot into gear – via a King of Comedy style scenario in which the footballer (the actor's lines conspicuously and distractingly dubbed) ends up becoming the girls' helpless captive – things went downhill so quickly. As with so many British movies at the moment, skilled directorial and technical contributions – plus a couple of strong performances – were fatally undermined by scriptwriting deficiencies (including the clumsy integration of a gun to raise the stakes in the latter stages.)
#6.2 (11.15pm, Sunday 21st June)
Even worse scripting issues mar A Boy Called Dad, in which a 14-year-old lad from New Brighton gets a girl pregnant and, months later, and following a string of unlikely developments, goes on the run with the resulting baby. The introduction of a firearm occurs much earlier than in Kicks, and this startlingly implausible occurrence sets the scene for pretty much all that's to follow. Though apparently Ken-Loachian in its depiction and dramatisation of a very real problem that's far from uncommon in modern Britain (where teenage pregnancy rates are notoriously among the world's highest), the movie quickly spirals into melodramatic absurdity.
Then again, such deficiencies are frequently to be found in Loach's own output in recent years, since he hooked up with writer Paul Laverty. Once again, there's nothing wrong with the performances – Ian Hart, as our hero's own dad, mines every scrap of humour and pathos from his role, while young Kyle Ward is quite a find as the title-character. Fingers crossed that Shane Meadows – in town shortly for Le Donk – will find a role for him in his next project.
Proof that excessive melodrama is by no means a problem restricted to British shores, The Architect is a glum, slow-moving character-based drama in which a successful Hamburg-based architect returns home to a mountain village (in the Tirol, Austria, though this is never made explicit in the script) to attend his mother's funeral. He's accompanied by his wife and student-age kids, and a right dysfunctional family they are too. Their presence in this insular, old-fashioned spot opens up long-buried secrets in a plot which turns out to be rather more Peyton Place than Christian Petzold, plodding along to its underwhelmingly downbeat finale. It's the kind of thing one imagines playing well at 10pm on Sunday night German TV, but at 9am on a Scottish cinema-screen it only intermittenly engaged my interest.
I likewise struggled to maintain proper critical attention towards No Puedo Vivir Sin Ti, a behind-the-headlines dramatisation of a 'Fathers 4 Justice' type case that was apparently a big story in Taiwan a couple of years back. A fortysomething bloke, eking out a living on a busy provinicial waterfront (an intriguingly busy real-world setting), has his daughter taken into care due to a cruel bureaucratic loophole involving his ex-partner's marital status. His struggles with two-faced officialdom tip him into increasingly erratic behaviour, with unfortunate consequences for all.
Shot on monochrome DV (blown up to celluloid), the images occasionally have the bygone feel of 1940s Italian neo-realism or Japanese pictures from the 1930s. But beneath the budget-transcending stylistics, this is a rather thin and sentimental story, its tearjerking aspects underlined by an intrusive score.
My researches have yet to come up with any reason why the film's title ("I can't live without you") should be in Spanish – a simple case of mucho pretentioso, I suspect.
~~~
Jigsaw Lounge Edinburgh 2009 index page
THE ARCHITECT : [5/10] : Der Architekt : Germany 2008 : Ina WEISSE : 93m : seen Cineworld, 20th June (press show)
A BOY CALLED DAD : [4/10] : UK 2009 : Brian PERCIVAL : 80m : Cineworld, 20th June (public show – complimentary ticket)
JERICHOW : [6/10*] : Germany 2008 : Christian PETZOLD : 93m : Cineworld, 19th June (public show – £6.00) – *originally rated 7/10 after first viewing, Jan.09
NO PUEDO VIVIR SIN TI : [5/10] : Bu neng mei you ni : Taiwan 2009 : Leon DAI : 91m : seen Filmhouse, 20th June (press show)
KICKS : [6/10] : aka K I C K S : UK 2008 : Lindy HEYMANN : 84m : Cineworld, 20th June (public show – complimentary ticket)



