DUTCH FILM-FESTIVAL’S LONG BATTLE TO ‘XL’ : Rotterdam 2011

If New York is the “city that never sleeps”, then Rotterdam is – according to the title of a 1928 documentary made in about Europe’s biggest port – The City That Never Rests. Directed by Friedrich von Maydell and shot by Holland’s leading cameraman of the era, Andor von Barsy, De stad die nooit rust was intended as an hour-long inducement to potential investors – but now stands as an inadvertently poignant record of a metropolis whose historic centre was flattened by Luftwaffe bombing only a dozen years later.

For decades available solely in edited form, a restored version of von Maydell and von Barsy’s movie was unveiled earlier this month as part of the 40th International Film Festival Rotterdam (IFFR). Attracting well over 300,000 patrons each year to its film-showings, live performances and exhibitions, IFFR proclaims itself the Netherland’s biggest cultural event.

And that bustling restlessness manifests itself in sheer number and breadth of films selected. Over the course of eleven days, more than 200 features and dozens of shorts-programmes are shown across half a dozen venues – the first screenings kicking off just after 9am, and many auditoria closing their doors after midnight. The more conscientious patrons head home, while their more hedonistic peers repair to nearby watering-holes including ‘Chez Alain’, the legendary bar at the Grand Hotel Central. This is a cramped, crowded, smoky spot which eerily resembles a British boozer circa the period when Hubert Bals and his pals set up IFFR (as ‘Film International’) in 1972.

The ‘Central’ (always pronounced Dutch-style with a long ‘a’) isn’t to everyone’s tastes, but can justifiably be regarded as the festival’s true heart. Here filmmakers (some pretty illustrious, many just starting out), journalists and the public mingle in a boisterously egalitarian atmosphere – and countless fruitful collaborations (of all kinds) have been forged here down the decades.

Every now and again there’s talk of the council demolishing the Central, despite the fact that Rotterdam doesn’t exactly have a surfeit of pre-1940 inner-city buildings. Likewise, one frequently hears predictions that the finest IFFR cinemas – the mirror-walled, deliciously retro Luxor, which looks more like a burlesque nightclub than a kino, mere yards from the Central – is also living on borrowed time.

These are classic examples of bureaucracies undervaluing unique cultural assets, and conspiracy theorists regularly point to the council’s ongoing development of the increasingly-upmarket Kop Van Zuid area south of the river-dividing Maas river. Already one long-standing venue, Lantaren/Venster, has relocated “down south”, a breezy 20-minute walk (over the soaring, swan-like landmark that is the Erasmus Bridge) from the rest of the festival amenities. Rotterdam regulars worry that more of the festival’s relatively compact ‘gezellig’ cosiness will soon be sacrificed in the name of (yuppie-friendly) progress.

It’s debatable whether or not the programme alone would be enough to keep international visitors coming back year after year, as Rotterdam – which trades heavily on being a “public” festival that sells many thousands of tickets – has long shown far too many films, with quantity too often getting the upper hand over quality (the choice of ‘XL’ to brand the overstuffed 40th festival smacked of making a virtue out of bigger-is-better necessity.)

The enterprise’s eclecticism and sheer scale ensures there’s something for all tastes – from relatively accessible US “indie” fare such as Black Swan, Blue Valentine and Somewhere, to more taxing propositions from exotic experimenta farthest geographical and conceptual reaches. But picking one’s way through the tangled strands of the sprawling programme can be a hazardous business, with many duds (and, for the more impatient, walkouts) along the way.

Nevertheless, as a multi-panelled snapshot of Planet Cinema – from high creative peaks to the lowest troughs – Rotterdam continues to serve a valuable purpose. And over the course of its 40th edition, the following features stood out as worthy of tracking down if and when they make it to these shores.

Finisterrae
was for many the discovery of Rotterdam 2011, a wonderfully unlikely blend of high art and low comedy from Sergio Caballero – one of the creators of Barcelona’s acclaimed Sónar music-festival, and also reportedly no mean wine-grower. Making his feature debut in his mid-forties, renaissance-man Caballero has crafted a deadpan fable of refreshingly original texture, one which incorporates elements of Beckett and Buñuel (one senses both geniuses would approve), plus highbrow spiritual cinema from Bergman and Tarkovsky to the sub-genre’s current practitioners such as Caballero’s own Catalan countryman Albert Serra.

But as this unlikely saga unfolds – a pair of shrouded Russian ‘ghosts’ trek the ancient pilgrim-path to Santiago de Compostela in damp, windy northern Spain, then on to Cape Finisterre in search of rebirth – a more freewheelingly offbeat vibe (part Monty Python, part Alejandro Jodorowsky) quickly emerges.

The results are frequently hilarious and, despite being shot on high-definition digital video, seldom less than painterly to look at. The cinematographer is 29-year-old prodigy Eduard Grau, also responsible for Tom Ford’s A Single Man, Rodrigo Cortes’ Buried and Serra’s Honour of the Knights, and who delivers a final reel that’s about as exquisitely beautiful as cinema gets these days.

Spectacularly divisive among critics (several of whom loudly expressed their bemused derision during and after the press-show), Finisterrae quickly gained something like “instant cult” status among the Rotterdam ticket-buyers. It was rightly – if perhaps surprisingly – rewarded with one of IFFR’s three equal top prizes, the Tiger Awards, in a 14-strong competition section restricted to first/second-time directors.

The other Tigers proved more predictable, going to relatively conventional art-movie fare in the form of Thailand’s partly IFFR-funded romance Eternity by Sivaroj Kongsakul (the next Apichatpong Weerasethekul? Time will tell), and strong critical favourite The Journals of Musan, a chronicle of the mishaps befalling a meek North Korean defector in Seoul, by Park Jung-Bum.
Park had previously worked as assistant to Lee Chang-Dong on the much-admired Poetry, and with the likes of Hong Sang-Soo, Kim Ki-Duk and Bong Joon-Ho kicking around, it’s clear that South Korea is continuing to punch far above its weight in terms of international cinematic renown.

The next big thing from below the 38th parallel may well be Yoon Sung-Hyun, present in competition at Rotterdam with his remarkably assured debut feature Bleak Night, the 29-year-old’s film-school graduation project. An ambitious, intelligent and convincing examination of the turbulent dynamics between a trio of late-teenage boys, Bleak Night tackles the subjects of bullying and suicide with a gritty, steely sensitivity and is built four-square around a trio of fine performances by the youthful leads.

An East Asian combination of Gus Van Sant’s Elephant and Channel 4’s Skins, Bleak Night is especially relevant as South Korea has long suffered from one of the world’s highest suicide-rates, which some commentators reckon is partly attributable to the pressures to conform and succeed felt by many of its younger citizens.

Outside the competition section – though significantly stronger than many films which did (for inexplicable reasons) vie for the Tiger prizes – lurked a promising talent who, unlike Bleak Night‘s Yoon, hasn’t even completed his studies yet. Swiss writer-director Michael Krummenacher shot Beyond These Mountains (which he co-wrote with Silvia Wolkan) over the course of 20 days in his home-town of Schwyz with a bunch of friends and film-school colleagues, almost all of them still in their twenties, and all for a reported budget of €20,000.

Audiences who got past the unappealing video surfaces of the movie were rewarded with a slyly humourous but psychologically penetrating study of two young women and their less-than-healthy friendship – somewhat in the vein of Erick Zonca’s enduringly influential Dream Life of Angels (1999), but finding its own decidedly Swiss tone of quietly suffocating eeriness and boosted by Krummenacher’s flair at exploiting the depths and planes of the frame (a technique which so few directors even attempt these days.)

While festivals like Rotterdam are for many all about recognising the next wave of young auteurs from around the globe, there is also – in such a vast programme – plenty of space to reconnect with older masters. Longtime IFFR favourite Takashi Miike (Audition) returned with a brace of violent features including the rousing samurai epic Thirteen Assassins (UK release set for May 6th) – very timely, given the festival’s ‘Dragon Tiger Inn’ selection of martial-arts classics from nearly every decade of the 20th century. From Russia, contrasting examples of the nation’s tradition of soulful, pitch-black humour came from sexagenarian Svetlana Proskurina – courtesy of the beautiful nightmare that is her rural picaresque Truce (showcased at last November’s London Film Festival) – and from veteran provocateur Alexei Balabanov. The latter’s bleakly witty miniature The Stoker sees a concussed Afghan war hero eking out a living tending apartment-block boilers – their furnaces proving very useful to cops and criminals alike when inconvenient corpses require speedy disposal.

Sticking to the fiery theme, keep an eye out for Denis Villeneuve’s harrowing Incendies from Quebec (based on Wajdi Mouawad’s stage-play Scorched). Wide-margin winner of the IFFR audience award, this gripping thriller of family secrets plays out against a complex backdrop of middle-east politics over several decades decades, and is front-runner for the Oscars’ Foreign Language category (February 27th.) At the time of writing Ladbrokes are offering a generous 3/1 – and, who knows, a successful wager might fund your visit to that restless Dutch port for ‘XLI’ next January…

Neil Young
8th February 2011
written for the following week’s edition of Tribune magazine